Putting it together

All it takes to be a composer is to write a melody. Everything else -- the chords, the harmonies, the structure, the key, the countermelodies, the bass line, the intro, the outro, and anything else you can think of is "the arrangement".

Sure, some composers, especially those with classical training, are their own arrangers. But in the theatre world and in the pop world, there are usually one or more folks hard at work shaping the music and creating all of the elements of the music that aren't the actual melody. And to further complicate matters, sometimes the composer is actively involved, sometimes they're disinterested, and sometimes they're dead. That last category in particular doesn't give a lot of feedback.

Here's my favorite metaphor: if this were the world of art, all the composer would have to say is "I imagine a tree". Of course, they may or may not give you other information: "it's a pine tree"…"it's in a forest"… "it's winter". It's up to the arranger to fill in ALL of the remaining details of the black-and-white sketch to create something that is ready for viewing. (And to further the metaphor, it's the orchestrator who adds the color).

(Side note: it was common practice to refer to Orchestrators as Arrangers back in the heyday of the recording industry - think Billy May, Nelson Riddle, etc. - but nowadays, at least in the theatre world, these are distinct jobs).

Amongst arrangers, it's generally accepted that there are four distinct kinds of arranging:

  1. Vocal Arranging -- just like it sounds, this is figuring out what people are singing if they're not singing the melody. To me, AnnMarie Milazzo (Spring Awakening) is the undisputed master, and she does it, amazingly, without reading or writing music -- it's all by ear. Astonishing. Of course, Choral Arranging (meaning writing specifically for a choir) is a related field, and like vocal arranging, works best when there's a real understanding of the human voice.
  2. Incidental Music Arranging -- figuring out underscores and transitions. This requires a keen sense of the dramatic pacing of scenes, as well as understanding how to tailor music to 'how long does it take the set to move?' Usually, the themes are drawn from the composer's melodies, but there are all sorts of compositional tricks that can be used -- reharmonizing, re-shaping, fragmentation, turned melodies upside down.
  3. Dance Arranging -- this is a biggie, especially for me. The Dance Arranger is the liaison between the composer and the choreographer. In the simplest terms, it's shaping the music to complement the visual. The relationship of the choreographer to the dance arranger is one of the most symbiotic and collaborative in all of theatre. Like the Incidental Music Arranger, you're using every compositional tool in the book, and when it's at it's best, dance music becomes an essential part of a show and its storytelling. Think the 'Carousel Ballet' or 'Small House of Uncle Thomas' both written by Trude Rittmann, using bits of Rodgers' melodies here and there. Or Peter Howard, not John Kander, wrote 'The Hot Honey Rag'.
  4. Song Arranging -- a truly broad category that essentially covers all of the songs in a score. It often includes elements of all of the other arranging jobs, especially vocal arranging if, say, the song is a duet. But a deep understanding of dramatic and storytelling needs is essential.

There is a huge amount more to be written about this, but suffice it say that the terminology is insufficient. I've often just used the term "Music Arranger" or "Score Adaptor" when I've done a show where I've touched every aspect of the shaping of the music.

American Classic

2026 MGM+ Series

view project

The Bride

A film by Maggie Gyllenhaal

view project

And Just Like That…

"Forget About the Boy"
Season 3, Episode 11

view project

Étoile

2025 Amazon Prime Series

view project

Schmigadoon! The Musical

2025 Kennedy Center Production
2026 Original Broadway Production

view project

Joker: Folie à Deux

A Todd Phillips film
Warner Bros. Pictures

view project

Love Child

A Todd Solondz film

(in production)

view project

1776

2022 Broadway Revival

view project

The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel (Season 4)

2022 Amazon Prime Series

view project

The Bedwetter

2022 The Atlantic Theater Co.
2025 Arena Stage

view project

The Music Man

2022 Broadway Revival Production

view project

Goliath

"Pain Killer"
Season 2, Episode 4

view project

The New Classics

Lyric Opera of Chicago

view project

Halston

2021 Netflix Series

view project

West Side Story

2020 Broadway Revival

view project

Tootsie

2019 Original Broadway Production

view project

Kiss Me, Kate

2019 Broadway Revival

view project

We’ll Have Manhattan: Rodgers & Hart in New York

The 92nd Street YMCA "Lyrics & Lyricists" Concert Series

view project

Future Man

"I Know This Isn't Real But I Don't Care"
Season 2, Episode 8

view project

Carousel

2018 Broadway Revival Production

view project

Frozen

2018 Original Broadway Production

view project

Anastasia

2017 Original Broadway Production

view project

Dreamgirls

West End Revival Production

view project

Tuck Everlasting

2016 Original Broadway Production

view project

My Paris

2015 Goodspeed at Chester
2016 Long Wharf

view project

Damsel in Distress

2015 Chichester Festival Production

view project

Finding Neverland

2015 Original Broadway Production

view project

A Funny Thing Happened: Songs from the Road to Broadway

2015 92nd Street Y Concert

view project

Side Show

2014 Broadway Revival Production

view project

Going Hollywood

2014 92nd Street Y Concert

view project

Cat on a Hot Tin Roof

2013 Broadway Revival

view project

Elf The Musical (2012)

Broadway Encore Production

view project

Nice Work If You Can Get It

2012 Original Broadway Production

view project

Evita

2012 Broadway Revival Production

view project

Anything Goes

2011 Broadway Revival
2021 London Revival

view project

Elf The Musical (2010)

Original Broadway Production

view project

Robin and the 7 Hoods

2015 Old Globe Production

view project

Promises, Promises

2010 Broadway Revival

view project

The Kennedy Center Honors Jerry Herman

2010 Television Broadcast

view project

Dreamgirls

2009 Broadway Revival Tour

view project

Bye Bye Birdie

2009 Broadway Revival

view project

Cry-Baby

2008 Original Broadway Production

view project

The Little Mermaid

2008 Original Broadway Production

view project

The 12 Days of Christmas

The Boston Pops

view project

Grease

2007 Broadway Revival

view project

Curtains

2007 Original Broadway Production

view project

Carnival

2007 Kennedy Center Production

view project

The Kennedy Center Honors Steve Martin

2007 Television Broadcast

view project

The Wedding Singer

2006 Original Broadway Production

view project

The Pajama Game

2006 Broadway Revival

view project

Guys and Dolls

2005 West End Production

view project

Beyond the Sea

A film by Kevin Spacey

view project

Lucy Simon at Joe's Pub

2009 Concert celebrating Lucy Simon
2024 Concert celebrating the life of Lucy Simon

view project

The Music Man

2003 TV Film

view project

House of Flowers

2003 Encores! Production

view project

Flower Drum Song

2002 Broadway Revival Production

view project

Thoroughly Modern Millie

2002 Original Broadway Production

view project

Flower Drum Song

2001 Ahmanson Theatre Production

view project

Follies

2001 Broadway Revival

view project

Seussical, The Musical

2000 Original Broadway Production

view project

Little Me

1998 Broadway Revival

view project

The Scarlet Pimpernel

1998 reworking of 1997 Original Broadway Production

view project

Side Show

Original Broadway Production

view project

Radio City Christmas Spectacular

view project

Frozen Original Broadway Cast Recording

Zest (Harvard Din and Tonics)

listen now

Joker: Folie à Deux (Music From The Motion Picture)

listen now

The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel: Season 5 (Music from The Prime Original Series)

listen now

Halston (Music from the Netflix Series)

listen now

Pain Killer (From the Amazon Original Series Goliath) (single)

listen now

Original Music From The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel Season 3

listen now

Crazy Ex-Girlfriend Season 4 Original Television Soundtrack

listen now

Crazy Ex-Girlfriend Season 3 Original Television Soundtrack

listen now

Season of Light: Songs of Thanksgiving (EVUSA)

listen now

Holiday Harmonies: Songs of Christmas (EVUSA)

listen now

Rejoice! Honoring the Jewish Spirit (EVUSA)

listen now

A Boston Pops Christmas - Live from Symphony Hall

listen now

The Red Sox Album (Boston Pops)

listen now

Beyond the Sea (Soundtrack)

listen now

The Harvard Krokodiloes - The 50th Anniversary Album

listen now

"Wayfaring Stranger" (Kroks)

listen now

Radio City Christmas Spectacular (Cast Recording)

listen now

Yuletide Carols (Hal Leonard)

listen now

Hometown Christmas Postcard (Hal Leonard)

listen now

Together at Christmas (Hal Leonard)

listen now

This Old Hammer (Hal Leonard)

listen now

Down in a Coalmine (Hal Leonard)

listen now

Adonai Roi (Psalm 23) (Hal Leonard)

Sing Christmas – The Carol Arrangements of David Chase (Hal Leonard)

listen now

Angels We Have Heard on High (Hal Leonard)

listen now

Give Me Your Tired, Your Poor (SAB)

listen now

The First Noel (Hal Leonard)

listen now

Songs of Peace (Hal Leonard)

listen now

Give Me Your Tired, Your Poor (SATB) (Hal Leonard)

listen now

Who Will Come and Go with Me? (Hal Leonard)

listen now

Appalachian Stories: A Song Cycle

listen now

"The 12 Days of Christmas" (single)

listen now

Julie and Friends (Recording)

listen now

Let's
Collaborate

get in touch